Illinois Slip and Fall Claims
What You Need to Know After a Fall at a Business
By Shaun Cusack, Illinois Personal Injury Attorney | Cusack & Gilfillan LLC
A fall at a grocery store, restaurant, hotel, shopping center, parking lot, apartment building, or other business can result in serious injuries. Broken wrists, shoulder injuries, knee injuries, concussions, back injuries, and hip fractures are all common consequences of falls.
But the fact that someone was injured on a business’s property does not automatically make the business legally responsible.
Illinois slip and fall cases are highly dependent on the facts. The key questions usually include what caused the fall, who created the dangerous condition, whether the business knew or should have known about it, how long the condition existed, and whether reasonable steps were taken to protect customers.
At Cusack & Gilfillan LLC, Illinois personal injury attorneys Dan & Shaun Cusack evaluate these cases by focusing early on the evidence that can prove—or disprove—those questions.
What Is Premises Liability in Illinois?
“Premises liability” is the general term for claims involving injuries caused by dangerous conditions on property.
Under the Illinois Premises Liability Act, 740 ILCS 130/2, an owner or occupier of property owes lawful entrants a duty of reasonable care under the circumstances regarding the condition of the premises and activities occurring there.
That does not make a store or property owner an insurer of everyone’s safety.
In a typical Illinois slip and fall case, an injured person may need to establish that:
- A dangerous condition existed;
- The defendant owed the injured person a duty of reasonable care;
- The defendant created the dangerous condition or knew—or reasonably should have known—about it;
- The defendant failed to take reasonable precautions;
- The dangerous condition caused the fall; and
- The fall caused actual injuries and damages.
The details surrounding each of those issues matter.
What Types of Conditions Can Cause an Illinois Slip and Fall?
Slip and fall cases can arise from many different conditions, including:
- Spilled liquids;
- Leaking coolers or refrigeration equipment;
- Tracked-in rainwater;
- Snow and ice;
- Uneven sidewalks or pavement;
- Broken concrete;
- Potholes;
- Torn or loose carpeting;
- Wet floors;
- Poor lighting;
- Missing or defective handrails;
- Cords or objects across walkways;
- Merchandise left in aisles; and
- Defective stairs or walking surfaces.
The type of hazard can completely change the investigation.
For example, a customer spilling a drink moments before another person falls presents a very different legal issue from a refrigeration unit that has been leaking repeatedly for weeks.
Did the Business Know About the Dangerous Condition?
In many Illinois premises liability cases, one of the most important questions is whether the business had notice of the dangerous condition.
There are several ways notice may be established.
The Business Created the Hazard
A business may be responsible when its own employees created the condition.
Examples might include an employee who mops a floor without placing appropriate warning signs, leaves merchandise in a walkway, or causes a spill while stocking shelves.
The Business Actually Knew About the Hazard
Evidence of actual notice can include:
- An employee seeing the condition;
- A customer previously reporting it;
- A maintenance request;
- An incident report;
- An employee placing a cone or warning sign nearby; or
- Surveillance footage showing employees encountering the condition.
The Condition Existed Long Enough That It Should Have Been Discovered
This is often referred to as constructive notice.
Evidence such as footprints through a spill, cart tracks, dirt, drying edges, surveillance footage, inspection logs, cleaning schedules, employee testimony, or prior complaints may help determine how long a dangerous condition existed.
There is no universal rule saying a spill must remain on the floor for a particular number of minutes before a business can be responsible. The issue is generally whether the business acted reasonably under the circumstances.
What Should You Do After a Slip and Fall in Illinois?
The first few minutes and days after a fall can become extremely important.
At Cusack & Gilfillan LLC, Shaun Cusack frequently emphasizes preservation of evidence because the condition that caused a fall may disappear almost immediately.
Take Photographs and Video
If you are physically able, photograph the condition before it is cleaned, repaired, moved, or melted.
Take photographs from several distances and angles showing:
- The dangerous condition itself;
- The surrounding floor or walkway;
- Lighting conditions;
- Warning signs—or the absence of warning signs;
- Nearby displays or obstructions;
- Your clothing; and
- Your shoes.
A close photograph may establish what the condition looked like. A wider photograph can help show whether a person approaching the area would reasonably have noticed it.
Report the Fall
Tell a manager or responsible employee what happened and ask that an incident report be prepared.
Be accurate. Do not guess.
For example, if you do not know how long a liquid had been on the floor, do not estimate.
Write down the names of employees or managers with whom you spoke.
Identify Witnesses
Get names and contact information from anyone who:
- Saw the fall;
- Saw the dangerous condition before the fall;
- Heard employees discussing the condition;
- Reported the problem before your fall; or
- Witnessed your interaction with employees afterward.
Do not assume the business will preserve witness information for you.
Preserve Your Shoes and Clothing
Do not throw away, repair, or significantly alter the shoes and clothing you were wearing.
A defendant may later argue that footwear contributed to the fall. Preserving the actual shoes can prevent speculation about their condition.
Obtain Appropriate Medical Care
Seek medical attention if you are injured.
Describe accurately how the fall occurred and identify all injured areas of your body. Some injuries—particularly neck, back, head, knee, and shoulder injuries—may become more noticeable over the following hours or days.
Preserve Surveillance Video and Business Records
Many Illinois businesses use surveillance cameras.
Video may show:
- How a dangerous condition developed;
- How long it was present;
- Whether employees walked past it;
- Whether warning signs were present;
- The fall itself; and
- What happened immediately afterward.
The problem is that video may be automatically overwritten.
An attorney can send a preservation notice requesting that relevant surveillance footage, inspection logs, cleaning records, incident reports, photographs, employee records, and other evidence be preserved.
This is one reason contacting an attorney early can matter.
What If the Business Says the Danger Was “Open and Obvious”?
Property owners and insurance companies sometimes argue that the condition was so obvious that the injured person should have seen and avoided it.
Illinois recognizes what is commonly called the open-and-obvious doctrine, but the analysis is often more complicated than simply asking whether a hazard can be seen in a photograph taken after an accident.
The circumstances at the time of the fall matter.
Relevant facts may include:
- Lighting;
- Color contrast;
- Crowds;
- Merchandise displays;
- The direction the person was walking;
- Whether the person’s attention was reasonably distracted;
- Whether the person had to encounter the condition to proceed; and
- What the property owner should reasonably have anticipated.
Whether the open-and-obvious doctrine applies can become a significant issue in an Illinois premises liability case.
What Is Comparative Negligence in an Illinois Slip and Fall Case?
The defense may also argue that the injured person contributed to the accident by failing to watch where he or she was walking, ignoring a warning, using a phone, or wearing inappropriate footwear.
Illinois follows a modified comparative negligence system.
Under 735 ILCS 5/2-1116, an injured person who is more than 50% responsible for the injury cannot recover damages. If the person is 50% or less responsible, the damages awarded are reduced by that percentage of fault.
For example, if damages were $100,000 and the injured person were found 20% responsible, the recoverable damages would ordinarily be reduced to $80,000.
Fault percentages are often heavily disputed.
Who Can Be Responsible for a Slip and Fall?
The property owner is not always the only possible defendant.
Depending on the circumstances, responsible parties could include:
- A commercial tenant;
- A property management company;
- A maintenance contractor;
- A cleaning company;
- A snow and ice removal contractor;
- A construction company; or
- Another entity responsible for controlling or maintaining the area.
Determining who actually controlled the property and who was responsible for inspecting or maintaining it can be an important part of the investigation.
What Damages Can Be Recovered in an Illinois Slip and Fall Case?
Depending on the facts and injuries, damages may include compensation for:
- Medical expenses;
- Future medical treatment;
- Lost wages;
- Loss of future earning capacity;
- Pain and suffering;
- Disability;
- Disfigurement; and
- Loss of a normal life.
Every case is different. The seriousness of the injury is only one part of the analysis. How the injury affects a person’s work, activities, independence, and daily life can also be important.
Frequently Asked Questions About Illinois Slip and Fall Cases
Is a business automatically responsible if I fall on its property?
No. The fact that an injury occurred on someone else’s property does not automatically establish negligence. The circumstances surrounding the dangerous condition and the defendant’s knowledge or responsibility for it must be investigated.
What if the business cleaned up the spill before I could photograph it?
That does not necessarily prevent a claim. Surveillance video, witness testimony, employee testimony, incident reports, cleaning records, and other evidence may establish what happened.
What if I did not report my fall before leaving?
Failure to immediately report an accident does not automatically eliminate a claim, but it may make proving what happened more difficult. Document what occurred and notify the business as soon as reasonably possible.
What if I fell on snow or ice?
Illinois snow and ice cases involve additional legal issues, including whether an accumulation was natural or whether the property owner or another party created or aggravated the condition. Contracts, drainage conditions, snow-removal practices, and sometimes local ordinances may also matter.
Should I give the insurance company a recorded statement?
You should understand who is requesting the statement and why before giving one. Insurance companies investigate claims with their insured’s interests in mind. For a significant injury, it may be wise to speak with an attorney before providing a detailed recorded statement.
Talk to an Illinois Slip and Fall Attorney
Evidence in a premises liability case can disappear quickly. A spill gets cleaned. Snow melts. Surveillance footage gets overwritten. Employees leave. Memories fade.
Shaun Cusack of Cusack & Gilfillan LLC represents people injured because of dangerous property conditions throughout Illinois. Our firm can investigate what happened, determine who controlled the property, preserve surveillance footage and records, evaluate insurance coverage, and explain whether Illinois law provides a basis for recovery.
If you or a family member has suffered a serious injury in a fall at an Illinois store, restaurant, business, parking lot, apartment property, or other premises, contact Cusack & Gilfillan LLC to discuss what happened.
This article was prepared by Illinois attorney Shaun Cusack of Cusack & Gilfillan LLC and is intended for general informational purposes only. It is not legal advice, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends upon its individual facts.
More Learning Center Topics
Warning Signs of Nursing Home Neglect in Illinois
Attorney Shaun Cusack explains warning signs of Illinois nursing home neglect, including falls, bedsores and dehydration, plus what families should do next.
Illinois Workers’ Compensation Claim Denied? The Insurance Company Does Not Get the Final Word
You got hurt doing your job. Now you are dealing with pain, medical appointments….
What to Do After a Car Accident in Central Illinois
A serious car accident can change your life in seconds. Suddenly, you may be….
MILLIONS RECOVERED FOR OUR CLIENTS
Helpful resource: Illinois Premises Liability Act (740 ILCS 130) – the Illinois statute setting the duty of care property owners owe to visitors.
